India: Cease Utilizing Pellet-Firing Shotguns in Kashmir
Use Towards Spiritual Procession Induced Severe Accidents

Printed in


An Indian police officer goals a shotgun at Kashmiri protesters throwing stones, in Srinagar, India, Might 8, 2018.© 2018 AP Picture/Mukhtar Khan
(New York) – The Indian authorities ought to prohibit safety forces in Jammu and Kashmir from utilizing shotguns firing metallic pellets to disperse crowds, Human Rights Watch stated as we speak. Indian police and paramilitary forces fired shotguns in addition to tear fuel at a Shia Muslim procession in Srinagar on August 29, 2020, injuring dozens of individuals.

The forces opened fireplace after marchers in Muharram defied orders to disperse beneath a Covid-19 ban. This sparked violent protests by which some protesters threw stones, injuring 15 safety personnel, in response to the police.

“Repeatedly, Indian legislation enforcement’s use of shotguns in Kashmir has resulted in surprising, grievous accidents of protesters and bystanders,” stated Meenakshi Ganguly, South Asia director at Human Rights Watch. “Indian authorities want to acknowledge that this weapon fired into crowds, even with violent demonstrators, will invariably trigger indiscriminate and extreme harm in violation of worldwide requirements.”

Pellets fired from shotguns have brought on hundreds of accidents, together with lack of eyesight, within the decade since Indian authorities first deployed them as an ostensibly “non-lethal” possibility for crowd management, to switch dwell ammunition. The transfer got here after practically 120 folks had been killed in Kashmir throughout weeks of violent protests in 2010.

Safety forces usually use 12-gauge pump motion weapons to fireside cartridges which can be crammed with dozens or lots of of small metallic pellets, that are typically known as “birdshot” or “dove shot” to replicate their position in searching. Whereas initially concentrated in a decent sample as they’re fired, the pellets unfold out to create a constellation that may attain a large radius, inflicting accidents indiscriminately, together with to bystanders.

The Indian authorities have claimed that safety forces use pellets solely when mandatory and in response to violence by protesters. Nevertheless, worldwide legislation bars any use of drive, together with in opposition to violent protesters, that causes indiscriminate or pointless hurt.

Safety forces’ use of shotguns in Kashmir has brought on deaths in addition to accidents. Whereas there isn’t a correct knowledge on casualties from shotgun-fired pellets, the Residence Affairs Ministry informed Parliament in February 2018 that 17 folks had died from pellets between 2015 and 2017. Based on the info journalism web site IndiaSpend, pellets fired from shotguns blinded 139 folks between July 2016 and February 2019. In January 2018, Jammu and Kashmir Chief Minister Mehbooba Mufti informed the state meeting that 6,221 folks had been injured by pellets between July 2016 and February 2017 and amongst them, 782 folks had eye accidents.

The Workplace of the United Nations Excessive Commissioner for Human Rights (OHCHR) has stated that use of a shotgun “firing metallic pellets is likely one of the most harmful weapons utilized in Kashmir,” and has referred to as for a right away finish to their use for crowd management.

In 2017, when questioned in parliament over the usage of pellets, the Residence Affairs Ministry stated it had explored different non-lethal alternate options to disperse crowds, however that “if these measures show to be ineffective in dispersing of rioters, use of pellet weapons could also be resorted to.” In December 2016, the Supreme Court docket stated that the these weapons shouldn’t be used “indiscriminately or excessively” in Kashmir and that the authorities ought to use them solely after “correct software of thoughts.”

In August 2016, the safety forces informed the Jammu and Kashmir Excessive Court docket that it used cartridges containing 450 metallic pellets every. The federal government has refused to launch data on the metallic utilized in these cartridges, citing nationwide safety considerations, although a physician in Srinagar stated they had been normally a “lead ball.” Whereas smaller pellets normally trigger painful however superficial accidents, they may also be deadly after they strike weak physique elements such because the eyes. Authorities statements additionally reveal that paramilitary forces in Jammu and Kashmir are given solely a three-day particular coaching on the usage of less-lethal weapons, together with shotguns.

The UN Fundamental Rules on the Use of Power and Firearms “[p]rohibit the usage of these firearms and ammunition that trigger unwarranted harm or current an unwarranted threat.” The UN Human Rights Committee, which screens compliance with the Worldwide Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, said in its Basic Remark No. 37 that “Firearms usually are not an applicable device for the policing of assemblies, and must not ever be used merely to disperse an meeting.… [A]ny use of firearms by legislation enforcement officers within the context of assemblies have to be restricted to focused people in circumstances by which it’s strictly essential to confront an imminent menace of dying or severe harm.”

The 2020 UN steerage on “less-lethal weapons” in legislation enforcement says, “A number of projectiles fired on the identical time are inaccurate and, generally, their use can’t adjust to the ideas of necessity and proportionality. Steel pellets, equivalent to these fired from shotguns, ought to by no means be used.”

“Indian leaders who declare that their insurance policies are bettering the lives of Kashmiris can’t disregard that safety forces are maiming, blinding, and killing folks,” Ganguly stated. “The Indian authorities ought to stop the usage of shotguns firing metallic pellets and overview its crowd management strategies to fulfill worldwide requirements.”

Associated Content material
India: New Reviews of Extrajudicial Killings in Kashmir India: Abuses Persist in Jammu and Kashmir India Failing on Kashmiri Human Rights

Area / Nation


Supply URL: